Rick Gets 45 MPG in Town in a 2017 Forester by Driving Slow

A tailgater closes in behind a 2017 Subaru Forester on a city street in Iowa. The Forester drops to 20mph and stays there. A block or two later, the other driver works out how to steer around it. Behind the wheel is Crazy uncle Rick. Rick is 75 or older, lives alone in an urban area, and bought the car new. It now has between 25,000 and 75,000 miles on it. Nothing major has gone wrong. Rick spent under $250 on repairs and maintenance last year, and rates the car 9 for overall satisfaction. It is a six-speed manual, by choice. Rick doesn't like CVTs, and enjoys knowing that 82% of people can't drive the car. Rick drives slow on purpose, and the numbers show the payoff: up to 45 mpg in town, in a car that is not the hybrid. The story also covers backup camera glare, a luggage rack Rick never uses, and why he keeps coming back to Subaru.
| Vehicle | 2017 Subaru Forester 2.i |
|---|---|
| Where | Iowa |
| Age range | 75+ |
| Household | Just me |
| Bought | New |
| Miles on it now | 25–75k |
| Repair spend last year | Under $250 |
| Overall satisfaction | 9 |
What real-world fuel economy or range do you get, and how do you drive?
30 and 40s in town. 33 on hwy. Slow . Enjoy teaching tailgaters 20mph is maximum speed when I'm tailgated. They usually figure out how to turn their steering wheel after a block or two.
“Enjoy teaching tailgaters 20mph is maximum speed when I'm tailgated. They usually figure out how to turn their steering wheel after a block or two.”
Crazy uncle Rick
What do you love about it that reviews never mention?
The manual emergency brake allows you to control the car if you know how. Extreme mpg if you're willing to drive slow . I've achieved 45 mpg in town. Hybrid rated at 34mpg. I get 33 hwy at 68 mph. Hybrid $10,000 more .

What has gone wrong with it, in order, with roughly what each fix cost?
My 2017 Forester needs 1 new windshield wiper. Nothing else. My 1997 Outback needed a head gasket at 100.000 miles,then went another 100.000 miles. Nothing major after that . Don't like cvt transmission. That's why I have a manual 6 speed. Enjoy the fact 82 % of the population can't drive it.
What drives you crazy about it every day?
Glare on back up camera. Requires me to use mirrors oh no , the suffering. Don't have a back up alarm like trucks,so I rev my engine. Alexa has told me my Forester will go 127mph. I haven't tested that claim.

Why did you pick this vehicle over the others you looked at?
I've had Subaru's before that lasted 200,000 miles. Subaru's go through ice,mud, and snow when other cars won't. Their all wheel drive is full time all wheel drive. Subaru is not as fast, as quiet and not comfortable as other cars. Just reliable.
Would you buy the same one again? Why or why not?
Would buy the next higher trim . Mirrors with turn signals,heated seats. Keep the luggage rack. Don't use em. Manufacturers spend millions to improve aerodynamics,then slap on a rack and reduce it.
This story was shared by a reader through our survey and is published in their own words. We fix spelling, trim for length and remove personal details. How we publish stories.
